CITIES
  • Bangkok
  • Hong Kong
  • Mumbai
  • Shanghai
  • Singapore
  • Tokyo
CNN International
Register
Sign In
Home   Tokyo   Play   Anime decade: From 'Japan Cool' to 'cool
in
TOKYO
Events
Map
Weather
  • eat
  • drink
  • play
  • shop
  • sleep
  • TOKYO VISITOR'S GUIDE
  • ALL TOKYO STORIES
by Matt Alt
23 December, 2009



   
share
add to favorites
print
email
Log in or sign up to add this to your favorites!

Anime decade: From 'Japan Cool' to 'cooling off'

Matt Alt asks, how did Japan's national artistic treasure -- animation -- go from boom to bust during the first decade of the 21st century?
 
65%
Users liked this
 
 
Tell others what you think!
Japanese anime
We may be projecting, but there seems to be a hint of frustration in those giant eyes.

I will admit it: I was a teenaged anime fanatic. Encounters with anime classics in the 1970s and 1980s ignited a fascination with Japanese language and culture that drew me to the country, first as a tourist, then as a student and now as a resident. This personal journey makes reading -- and writing about -- the industry's recent stumbles all the more poignant.

I was surprised and shocked to witness the rise of anime in the 1990s, and now I feel those same emotions again as I watch it collapse in slow motion. Truly, the early 2000s timeline reads like the plot of an epic novel with an appropriately apocalyptic anime ending.

Here is a timeline of the last decade's greatest developments in anime.

2000: Thanks to a string of international successes in the mid-1990s, including hits like "Pokémon," "Gundam Wing," "Dragonball," and "Sailor Moon," Japan's anime industry finds itself enjoying unprecedented success both domestically and abroad. The majority of shows created for male anime fans are sci-fi epics, many featuring heroes piloting giant robots or protagonists who are robots themselves.

2001: American journalist Douglas McGray dubs Japan "a cultural superpower," while coining the phrase "gross national cool" to describe the outsized influence of Japanese entertainment. "Cowboy Bebop," a hip sci-fi series about bounty hunters in space, debuts on the US Cartoon Network's Adult Swim, creating new legions of foreign anime fans.

2002: Hayao Miyazaki's "Spirited Away" wins an Academy Award for Best Animated Feature, the first time the American film industry so recognizes an anime.

2003: The Wachovski Brothers commission a series of nine anime short films based on their smash-hit Matrix films. Dubbed "The Animatrix," it becomes one of the top selling anime titles abroad that year. Meanwhile, Quentin Tarantino incorporates a flashy anime sequence into "Kill Bill, Vol. 1."

2005: Just as foreign audiences are warming up to the idea that animated fare isn't just for kids, Japan's anime industry throws them a curve ball. The success of the novel and television series "Densha Otoko" -- an alleged "true story" about an otaku who gets up the nerve to ask out a "normal" woman he encounters on the train during his daily commute -- legitimizes and empowers the local otaku community. This in turn leads to more and more animated series aimed squarely at their demographic.

Because said demographic consists almost entirely of eternally single, socially awkward men, their tastes tend towards wish-fulfillment fantasy plots starring beautiful young lolitas -- who are willing to hang out with eternally single, socially awkward men. This fetishization of girlish naiveté and innocence is known as "moé," and it will dictate the industry's path for the remainder of the decade. Critics, however, believe that the development will potentially hamper Japan's ability to export anime, as the moé concept comes across as utterly creepy to most foreign audiences.

2006: The industry achieves peak revenues of ¥241.5 billion per year. More animated fare is being created than ever before. In spite of this apparent success, it becomes public that a third of people working in the anime industry make less than ¥1 million a year -- a poverty-level wage.

2007 - 2008: The first visible cracks appear in anime's hip facade. An overabundance of anime made purely for anime fans (rather than for the traditional demographic of children and teenagers) knocks down the average profits per title as hastily-animated niche productions flood the market. Anonymous complaints from industry insiders incensed at atrocious pay and working conditions continue to mount. More and more of the basic work needed to train the next generation, such as "in-betweeing" (the grunt work of animating the many intermediate cels between the key frames) is farmed out to second- and even third-world countries -- including by some reports, North Korea. This results in a serious hollowing out of the industry's future talent pool. Meanwhile in the United States, the number of anime shows airing in the television marketplace drops dramatically.

2009: The types of anime shows popular among Japanese and foreign fans continues to diverge. The most buzz-worthy domestic fare are super-niche moé and lolicon shows brimming with inside jokes and anime stereotypes that few other than dyed-in-the-wool otaku can decipher. In Japan, a poll conducted by the otaku matchmaking service Otakuma reveals that four out of five of the top shows watched by female anime fans are about giant robots, while four out of five of the top shows watched by male anime fans are about little girls.

While anime created for kids is on the wane, the debut of a life-sized, 18-meter tall life-sized version of the iconic 1970s robot hero Mobile Suit Gundam in a Tokyo park is greeted by some four million nostalgic fans over the course of its display. Many are grown fans who bring their children to see the thirty year old character.

Meanwhile, in a Japanese radio interview, director Mamoru Oshii publicly admits that he was forced to use computers to animate his latest film "Sky Crawlers," because there simply "aren't enough animators out there to let us do everything hand-drawn. They're not around anymore." The general feeling is that Japan may not be able to sustain its anime industry in the coming years.

What will the second decade of the 21st century have in store for this Japanese pop art form? Check back with CNNGo in 2020, and we'll let you know.




   
share
add to favorites
print
email
Log in or sign up to add this to your favorites!

Matt Alt runs AltJapan Co., Ltd., a Tokyo-based entertainment localization company that specializes in video games, comic books and other pop culture. He is also the co-author of "Super #1 Robot" (Chronicle, 2005), "Hello, Please! Very Helpful Super Kawaii Characters From Japan" (2007, Chronicle) and "Yokai Attack! The Japanese Monster Survival Guide" (2008, Kodansha International).

Read more about Matt Alt
Tags: otaku culture, Japan Cool, anime and manga
user comments and reviews (10)
view all hide all
RedRangiku18
5 March, 2010
I think this was a great article you wrote. For my personal opinion I absolutely love Japanese anime. I grew up watching Sailor Moon, Gundam series, Ruronni Kenchin, Big O, Outlaw Star and Tenchi Muyo. I love all of those animes. I love Spirited Away too! I think the anime they are making now is great like Blood Plus! The problem is that in America they need to show more Japanese anime because no offense to my country but they are making some stupid anime. Expecially on Cartoonnetwork and Nickalodeon. In america yall definately have a big fan base of anime lovers. Yall don't just have japanese anime fans you have caucasian and african americans. Cause im african american too and i love the japanese culture . I think yall need to bring back the really old anime like sailor moon, and tenchi muyo, especially outlaw star back to american television cause it is hard to watch these shows on the internet. In america the most popular anime is bleach and naruto. I also like rosario + vampire and one piece.
add your own
RedRangiku18
5 March, 2010
I think this was a great article you wrote. For my personal opinion I absolutely love Japanese anime. I grew up watching Sailor Moon, Gundam series, Ruronni Kenchin, Big O, Outlaw Star and Tenchi Muyo. I love all of those animes. I love Spirited Away too! I think the anime they are making now is great like Blood Plus! The problem is that in America they need to show more Japanese anime because no offense to my country but they are making some stupid anime. Expecially on Cartoonnetwork and Nickalodeon. In america yall definately have a big fan base of anime lovers. Yall don't just have japanese anime fans you have caucasian and african americans. Cause im african american too and i love the japanese culture . I think yall need to bring back the really old anime like sailor moon, and tenchi muyo, especially outlaw star back to american television cause it is hard to watch these shows on the internet. In america the most popular anime is bleach and naruto. I also like rosario + vampire and one piece.
Tensigh
16 February, 2010
Iceman57, I loved your intro. I'm glad this article has articluated so well why so many anime over the past few years has really turned crappy. This is a phenomenon that seems to affect all types of media; once a (movie series, TV series, comic series) becomes popular, the quality of the product goes down. I never really made the connection between Densha Otoko and the decline of anime. That's a good point. For me, the real problem was in 2002 when "Spirited Away" won the Oscar. For me, SA was one of Miyazaki's more mediocre works. Anybody seen Ponyo? No offense, but it's barely coherent. You know it's bad when even HE makes average films. I think the last anime I really enjoyed was Rurouni Kenshin.
iceman57
24 December, 2009
"Year 200X. Japan anime was devastated by an informatic war. Almost all anime-cels have become extinct. However, traditionnal anime has survived." (based on Fist of the North Star intro). History repeating, for sure, remember the evolution from fully painted sheets to several layers with the acetate of cellulose in the 1930s to save production time. In the 1970s 1980s, animation that rocked Matt's youth was consider at this time as pure crap compare to master Walt Disney. Now 30 years later anime got awards and cinemas crowded of audience increasing the demand. Born in the same era, informatic increased production speed like in automotive industry were labor work turned to robots on the penible tasks (Gundam are everywere) and offers to answer this increasing anime demand. Not shocked at all by oversea production. In the 1980s, Europe and Northern America externalised tons of works in Japan, now Japan industry simply externalise in South Korea or China. There's only one way left to maintain this industry in Japan for the next decade: In a recent interview for Ponyo movie, master Miyazaki confessed to "Le Monde" journalis his will to return to a traditionnal animation that explained reuse of anime cels in his production. The explanation he gave was that animation lost its soul by using computers and giving even more and more effects. Back to basics is the only way to preserve creativity, and the question of national treasure/museum to preserve a part of this global memories from all childrens of the 1980s.
eliza94
24 December, 2009
I agree with this article to some extent, that anime in America is falling fast, but it's not necessarily because the quality is decreasing. I remember the Pokemon phenomenon, and how for a while, you were the coolest kid on the block if you had a holographic charizard. Now talking about your pokemon cards might only get you a label as an anime freak. I'm 15 and I love anime, but I believe now it's really misunderstood. The anime stereotypes now are so overpowering that for most people I talk to, they think the proper term for anime is "Naruto" because it is so highly advertised in stores and on television. That's not the only thing out there. There is an anime for every taste. Many don't even include giant robots or ninjas. I enjoyed watching an anime that aired this spring called "K-On" about a group of high school friends who formed a band. No violence or creepy lolicon in that. Also, Hayao Miyazaki's movies are still going strong. People are just playing into anime stereotypes and not going to see them. This summer's release of "Ponyo" included beautiful animation and a fantastic story, but on opening weekend, only 5 people came ot one of the showings. If people would stop playing into the idea that anime is for geeks, and be more open minded, they might acually find that they enjoy anime.
unity100
24 December, 2009
i disagree strongly. from what i see, there may be a lull in the anime audience and their activities in front of tvs, but the anime activity on the internet seems to be growing exponentially as ever. its as if it has become a staple of internet. its inevitable going by without watching a few series. in regard to the quality of anime, i would quite easily say that 3d animations surpassed hand drawn animes. just watch Toradora!, which is a recent adaptation (the series finished only last april) of the light novel. you then can see the point 3d animations have come to. piracy etc cant be also blamed for any mishaps in revenues either, for already many studios are going the route of publishing their own animes directly from their websites, therefore garnering the revenues they wouldnt have by publishing them through tv channels. internet has been a good thing for anime, and its possible that many small studios or artists can come up and establish their presence through the internet. i would say that your assesments were rather too bleak, and seems to be rather too detached from 'the people', on the extreme corporate end of the issue. the times are people's times. not corporate times.
desertfx5
24 December, 2009
I agree with the comment that the economy is putting a damper on the anime industry. If you look at some of the major new series to come out in the past year, they are mainly either remakes or continuations of popular shows (Dragonball Kai - a remake of Z, Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood - remake that follows the manga, and Inuyasha - The Final Act). These are all relatively low-risk ventures since they rely on an already established fan base. To complicate matters, anime in the US reached a fad level that there was no way it could sustain, complicated by the fact that networks were cashing in on 20+ years of programming that had not yet been licensed in the US. Plus Cartoon Network has all but ceased to promote anime in favor of their own productions aimed at the adult market.
Akurelus
23 December, 2009
I think the main reason for the cooldown in anime is because of the economic times. There has been a lot of good anime this decade. Of course there are a few horrible ones like The Melancoly of Haruhi Suzumiya and Lucky Star but, there have been some good ones like, Monster, Death Note, Code Geass, Tengen Toppen Gurren Lagann, Full Metal Alchemist, Higurashi no Naku Koro Ni, etc. I think the main reason for the decline in anime is piracy, and and how long it takes for a anime to get licensed. Most of the time I have watched a entire anime series on the internet a year or two before it even gets licensed in the U.S. For example the 5th season of Sailor Moon, and one of my favorite anime's To Aru Majutsu no Index still has not been licensed in the states yet.
crucarmen
23 December, 2009
japan animation is not "traditionally dedicated to public of children and teenagers". most of adult public in japan are found of. in addition yes that's true, the world is not composed only of japan and US :) in europe japan animation is very appreciated, lots of fan, all adults. and lots of women... children like pokemon and dragon ball, but as soon as they grow up they discover the "dark side" of japanime, (princess mononoke, grave of the fireflies...) and they do appreciate. It happened what happens to all of us : the public of japanime grew up, and the kind of japanime watched changed too, but it never stopped. Last but not least : just be aware that morocco's little boys are absolutely found of dragon ball, another generation of adult fans of wonderful animation movies (you must absolutely watch "grave of the fireflies", which is one of the very few best wonders of animation movies I ever saw, emotion at the biggest point but never eye-catching, hardness or reality of children through the war, use of music and images with a sense of respect of childhood and deep understanding of children, in a word : a chef-d'oeuvre). and remember : god also created the rest of the world :) merry christmas and happy new year anyway !!!
Osakan
23 December, 2009
I hate to admit that I must agree with you about how anime industry has been going down in the last few years, content-wise.On the other hand, your view seems unexpectedly narrow for someone with a long history being an anime fan. The "abroad" you said is limited in the US, there aren't just Japan and US in the world, Matt Alt. Rather than blaming a child felt down, why not watch it struggle to stand up?
Jedikid129
23 December, 2009
At this point, they've garnered a large enough base to pander to who'll still shell out enough cash to make a profit, and all without the risk of trying to appeal to other potential market. In 2020 we're either going to be talking about the collapse of the industry, or how self-sustaining it's become by just making things for fans. Either way, the early decade isn't coming back, and maybe some American companies will stop animating in flash, start drawing and fill the void for "cool" shows.
add your own
Thank you - your submission is being reviewed by our staff.
you may also like
  1. Japan Cool(down): the troubled times of Japan's anime business
    FULL ARTICLE
  2. Video: A dancing Tokyo Storm Trooper in Singapore
    FULL ARTICLE
  3. Rock legend Gene Simmons' son in manga plagiarism storm
    FULL ARTICLE
  4. Akiba Kiss: Prepare to be anime-zed
    FULL ARTICLE
most
read
most
commented
世界一魅力的な都市: 東京が No. 1 な 50 の理由
Photo gallery: Sleep street
Kim-Asada rivalry spurs global cyber-warfare
The Tokyo Hot List: 20 people to watch
Anime decade: From 'Japan Cool' to 'cooling off'
Kim-Asada rivalry spurs global cyber-warfare
A new Japanese social epidemic: Walking on escalators
World's Greatest City: 50 reasons why Tokyo is No. 1
Anime decade: From 'Japan Cool' to 'cooling off'
4 best Tokyo burgers
Get CNNGo in your inbox
Be first to know with our daily and weekly newsletters subscribe
© 2010 Cable News Network
Turner Broadcasting System, Inc.
All Rights Reserved
Terms of Service | Privacy Guidelines | Advertise with us | Write for CNNGo | About us | Contact us | Share | Site Map