CITIES
  • Bangkok
  • Hong Kong
  • Mumbai
  • Shanghai
  • Singapore
  • Tokyo
CNN International
Register
Sign In
Home   Shanghai   Why don't Shanghainese people care about
in
SHANGHAI
Events
Map
Weather
  • eat
  • drink
  • play
  • shop
  • sleep
  • SHANGHAI VISITOR'S GUIDE
  • ALL SHANGHAI STORIES
by Xing Zhao
18 December, 2009



   
share
add to favorites
print
email
Log in or sign up to add this to your favorites!

Why don't Shanghainese people care about the environment?

Although Copenhagen might be headline news, what’s occupying Shanghainese people’s thoughts these days isn’t the environment
 
72%
Users liked this
 
 
Tell others what you think!
China Buzz
For many locals though, hazy days like this are the least of their problems.

For those who come to Shanghai for the first time, what strikes them the most is not only how tall the skyscrapers are, but also how smoggy the skies can be.

With the UN’s 2009 Climate Change Conference in Copenhagen still in the news, it seems almost politically incorrect to not talk about the environment; however, according to QQ.com, environmental issues barely make the daily list of concerns for average Shanghainese person.

What do people care about?

A survey done by China Comment Magazine (半月談) in Shanghai, Zhejiang, Jiangsu, Hebei, Shanxi, Sichuan, Chongqing and Guizhong reveals that the top three issues that people pay the most attention to are: the gap between rich and poor, health care, schooling and housing expenses and (un)employment.

I make RMB 770 per month. With this wage, can I afford environmental protection?
— Yue Zhi Shen, netizen

With China’s becoming increasingly “capitalized,” the income inequality has rapidly increased here. Netizen Lei Qincheng summarizes many peoples feelings by saying, “Food price have risen 15 percent this year. It feels like the only thing that isn’t raising is my wage.”

In additional to cost of living concerns, health care, schooling and housing expenses -- the three most expensive costs an average Shanghainese person has to face -- are attracting heated comments online. Netizen Zhui Xun Er Shi de Meng comments, “A trip to the hospital would cost ten years of my life savings and I can't even think about the expensive schooling I will have pay for my child.”

Even with the city’s economic growth, not everybody thinks Shanghai is the land of opportunities. Yu Guoan, a 45-year-old unemployed worker complains online that it's hard to find a new job, while Yang Hua, a recent university graduate says “there are too many [university] graduates and there are not enough jobs.”

Why the planet is not their top concern

Pollution and environmental issues, ranked No. 7 in the China Comment Magazine survey -- not among people’s top priorities. QQ.com put this idea to the test in an online poll asking users: “Have you done anything about the climate change?” 30 percent of the 13,150 people respondents voted for “yes” while 70 percent admitted they hadn’t.

Netizen Shan Guang Dian explains how, even with such a push toward green technology in China, this sentiment can still be true among the average Chinese citizen. “I can’t even afford to buy an apartment or to get married," say Shan Guang Dian. "How can anyone expect me to care about the environment?”

An internet user called Meng Shou says, “With climate change, it takes a hundred years for Maldives to sink, but with all the housing and rent problems I have, I wish I could live long enough to see that.” Yue Zhi Shen from Zhongshan agrees: “I make RMB 770 per month. With this wage, can I afford environmental protection?” 

It looks like Shanghai still has a long way to go before people in China’s fastest developing city and the seat of the green-themed 2010 Expo can afford to start thinking about environmental issues.




   
share
add to favorites
print
email
Log in or sign up to add this to your favorites!

Now a writer and art communicator based in Shanghai, Xing writes a LGBeat column for CityWeekend and has been covering Shanghai's LGBT issues since summer 2009.

Read more about Xing Zhao
Tags: environmental protection, environmental issues, Chinese netizens, China environment, china buzz
user comments and reviews (9)
view all hide all
Shanghaiese
15 March, 2010
Look at the Maslow's hierarchy of needs, and it will be difficult to find out why environment protection is not among the top of the list of Shanghaiese concern. And why Chinese have been expected to be the leader in the issue of environment protection, just because of our huge CO2 emission? And the failure of Copenhagen Climate Summer in 2009 is not caused by Chinese reluctance, but by Americans hegemonism and danish impotency. China is still labeled as a developing country with GDP per. capita at around $4000, just above the poverty level, UN sets up. It is therefore unfair and unreasonable to set up the same standard for those earning $40000 and those at $4000.
add your own
Shanghaiese
15 March, 2010
Look at the Maslow's hierarchy of needs, and it will be difficult to find out why environment protection is not among the top of the list of Shanghaiese concern. And why Chinese have been expected to be the leader in the issue of environment protection, just because of our huge CO2 emission? And the failure of Copenhagen Climate Summer in 2009 is not caused by Chinese reluctance, but by Americans hegemonism and danish impotency. China is still labeled as a developing country with GDP per. capita at around $4000, just above the poverty level, UN sets up. It is therefore unfair and unreasonable to set up the same standard for those earning $40000 and those at $4000.
gcdiscover
20 December, 2009
The day this photo was taken the temperature was 1 degrees. I have photos of the sky the day before and all you can see is clear blue skies and a few clouds. I walked around the city for hours both in the day and in the night and had no problems breathing. I was a tourist and was surprised at the lack of pollution... compared to my expectations.
Kosuke
20 December, 2009
Although I understand the importance of an effort for good environmet at the individual level, I suppose the care on environment is rather a problem of the government than personal one because it is a problem related to common welfare and is highly spending. In this point of view, this article, placing the importance on consciousness of the individuals, seems misleading. However, I think this article is implying that the Chinese government is nonresponsive on the environmental issue.
SlogforDream
20 December, 2009
i found some statistics of the air quality. i don't think it's so bad like the essay and you said. In the Environmental Monitoring Organization of Shanghai records, i can always find it's fine which you said "trouble breathing". If you want to know the truth but not someone's bulabula, see this Website: the quality of the air daily (differ in region) ~ http://www.semc.gov.cn/airdistrict/ records of the quality of the air in Shanghai ~ http://www.semc.com.cn/home/api/apicontract.aspx we can see from record, the quality of air in shanghai below "Fine" is 6.3% every year, and 60.8% is Fine, 29.3% is good. So i don't want to say it's a slander, but the author must have his own slant. And for this pic maybe just a outcome of a cold current. Ultimately, if you don't believe the author neither the EM org. Just be there and breath.
vix628
19 December, 2009
“I can’t even afford to buy an apartment or to get married," say Shan Guang Dian. "How can anyone expect me to care about the environment." Because it's not just about you, it's about the world Meng Shou says, “With climate change, it takes a hundred years for Maldives to sink, but with all the housing and rent problems I have, I wish I could live long enough to see that.” there are 300,000 people who are in more trouble than you
caminito
19 December, 2009
This is in an eggshell why the Chinese, being a poor country, can pose as successfull and rich, Paying 770 Yuan ($100) a month in the big city ($50 outside), with prices could be the half as here, doing nothing to protect the enviroment, no protection for workers by Unions (the only one is Government obedient and try to maintain the workforce quiet and worst of all, with the the western companies supplying the technology so they can manufacture in China and export to the USA and other, obviously they can gain the competition, but 90% of their population stay abjectily poor. And only the morons on Wall Street believe their statistics, which are manufactured in the offices of Mr. WEN! But the end will be the same as in Russia?? Remember the westen Press salivating and exalting their space achievement and arms, between other?
Quesera
19 December, 2009
Hi Brad, I wonder where in Shanghai you are.My son is there right now, and he says he can barely see 500m, and he has trouble breathing the air. He could use some bright blue sky , let us know which Shanghai you are referring to :)
BradShanghai
19 December, 2009
In Shanghai now looking at a beautiful bright blue sky.
MartinJJH
19 December, 2009
When you take photo for a river, you'd better take more patient and pick a day with good weather. When you choose a photo for a river, you'd better just simply use google to find the clearer picture. If you want to pick a foggy picture on some specific purpose, yes you made it!
add your own
Thank you - your submission is being reviewed by our staff.
you may also like
  1. Daily Hitlist: Google sets its sights on Baidu’s top stop
    FULL ARTICLE
  2. Video: ‘Changing Lives in China’
    FULL ARTICLE
  3. Why can't Shanghai befriend its migrant workers?
    FULL ARTICLE
  4. A portrait from above of Shanghai’s pollution
    FULL ARTICLE
most
read
most
commented
Three year-old Chinese hip-hop star
Hanggai: Sounds from the Mongolian grasslands -- right to your local rock stage
The Shanghai Pizza Hut salad bar challenge
The Shanghai Hot List: 20 people to watch
Why don't Shanghainese people care about the environment?
Why don't Shanghainese people care about the environment?
World's Greatest City: 50 reasons why Shanghai is No. 1
Confessions of a pickup artist
Chinese men head to Vietnam for the 'perfect wife'
Shanghai’s most decadent burger
Get CNNGo in your inbox
Be first to know with our daily and weekly newsletters subscribe
© 2010 Cable News Network
Turner Broadcasting System, Inc.
All Rights Reserved
Terms of Service | Privacy Guidelines | Advertise with us | Write for CNNGo | About us | Contact us | Share | Site Map